Hello my long distance people,
It has been a month since you sat for your final. I know you don't want to think anymore about EDU 3215. It's done and over with. But my people, i'm offering you an opportunity to make changes to your fate. But alas it is your choice.
The relationship between Heathcliff and Cathy has always fascinated me. My fascination is also based on how each of you people looks at this relationship differently.How would you categorize their relationship and are you as enchanted/enthralled as me with their twist of fate or are you repulsed by the ugliness shown by excessive emotions?
the way the author set up heathcliff and cathy's relationship managed to make me think what if heathcliff didn't overhear what cathy said about being able to marry to another rich guy, what if heathcliff did not believe what he overheard was true and barged in to confront cathy, what if what if.. there are so many what ifs.. haha.. however, the way the author wrote the story is really interesting because it managed to manipulate readers like me, for example, to rewrite the story again and set it to have a happy ever after ending..
ReplyDeleteTan Kai Lynn J38861
PREMITHA J38862
ReplyDelete“Wuthering heights” is such a rich and complex novel. It was very hard for me to understand the family web and the message in the novel. However, after a number of times reading it, I feel that both Cathy’s and Heathcliff’s relationship based purely on love. They love each other deeply and there are soul mates. It is well presented in the novel that Heathcliff's and Cathy's love is spiritual, unlike any usual love people have out of physical attraction. Their love has grown since childhood, as a playmate and a friend but pathetically ended in death.
It’s true that I was enchanted to the twist of fate which made them faced separation although they loved each other deeply. I might say fate overcomes their love and fate played the major role where they failed to bring their love till happy marriage life. Again, the fate played an important role when Cathy believed to marry Edgar for his social economic status and could still continue to love Heathcliff. She feels an ardent love for Heathcliff although she is married to Edgar whom she failed to show love. On the other hand, Heathcliff’s revengeful love grown stronger and he started to blame Edgar for Cathy's death and things become even worse. In a way, one can say Heathcliff’s repeated calls that Cathy is his soul, ended their love in death.
Thanks Dr Ju
Cathy and Heathcliff’s passion for one another seem to be the center of WH. The passion is stronger and more lasting than any other emotion displayed in the novel. Cathy‘s desire and passion for Heathcliff did not fade even though she had married Edgar. The love between them is twisted because of the brute force used on each other to show their love. Their love for each other is strangely asexual. The two of them do not kiss in dark hidden corners or arrange secret trysts as most adulterers do. Their refusal to change for each other seems to pull them together. Cathy has a streak of meanness which somewhat compliments with Heathcliff’s arrogance. They don’t really have any kind words for each other to say when they meet. In whole, their love and passion for each other followed them till their untimely death. Surprisingly I am not repulsive of their intense show of emotion but I find it intriguing that two people can display such hatred for each other yet love each other with such passion and force.
ReplyDeleteWell, what I can say about Heathcliff and Catherine’s relationship? I believe some parts in our lives are destined to happen but how we handle the matters purely rely on us. God gives us free will to make our own life. For example in the case of Heathcliff and Catherine’s love-relationship, Catherine buries her love by following the accepted path of the society 19th century. She marries into money. She cannot marry Heathcliff as he has no prospect. She also didn't show out her love to Heathcliff may be because she had considered their two different backgrounds. The concepts the family gave to her told her that she could not be together with Heathcliff because they had different background. From the points, fate does not play any role in deciding whom she is to be married. Catherine made her choice. She had decided her destiny by getting married to Hindley. Personally some people know by their own instincts if the choice is right or wrong but cannot resist making the wrong choice. So I don't think our lives are predestined or twisted by fate. We all have choices.
ReplyDeleteMOGANA(J38844)
ReplyDeleteHeathcliff is an orphan and adopted by Mr Earnshaw. Mrs Earnshaw or her son Hindley, a resentful man failed to shower their care for Heathcliff. Heathcliff was often abused. Despite that, Cathi’s friendship becomes a convincing and delightful aspect for him. As he indulges himself with the love and enduring passion for Cathi, she denies him for her social ambition. In addition, her desire for the social ambition makes her to marry Edgar Linton. Apart from that Cathi always had wild passion for Heathcliff. When Heathcliff sees Cathy for the first time after his running away, I sensed their intense love. Perhaps I melted for the first time, while reading the story. To be frank I expected him to take revenge on her, despite that he expressed his unbreakable love. “You must forgive me,for I struggled only for u”….”why did you betray your heart Cathy”. His genuine love was explicitly seen here. His attention and the love for her instantly captured my attention. I became aware of such unique love highlighted in Wuthering Heights and at the meantime I was obviously sad that the true lovers were not destined to lead their life together…
My heart says that Heathcliff and Cathy are deeply in love with each other, but the question that haunted me till now is “whether they really "love" each other? It’s a strange love, they love each other but heart each other. Heathcliff and Catherine are selfish and petty. Instead of being blissfully in love, Catherine marries someone else and breaks Heathcliff's heart. Too proud to tell each other their true feelings, they fight, storm and rage against each other, destroying themselves in the process. If i were giving a chance to choose, i would choose to dislike this novel, for its gloomy perspective, tragic outcome and psychological drama. However, Catherine and Heathcliff are perhaps more realistic than most other novel characters claim to be. They not only make mistakes, they cause debacles, completely devastate both people and places and ruin it all by blaming solely themselves. WH potrays the most significant examples of sick love and fatality through the constrictions of social inscrutability. It is an eternal fight between the forces of nature and man, between good and evil, between body and soul. In any case, WH stays as a novel of great beauty and devastating intensity.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteAfter I read the novel, I knew that Heathcliff and Catherine love each other very much. But they usually show their love through sarcasm and criticizing each other. So there are often fight and dispute between them. For example, in page 59, Heathcliff went to visit Catherine while Hindley was not at home. Afterwards, they had a fight. Catherine demanded," And should I always be sitting with you" and she grow more irritated. She grows more irritated because of her sorrow to Heathcliff, that she said something which is true. Furthermore, they are soul mates. They grew up together from childhood, and they really consider themselves to be two halves of the same person. They live in their own little world, and when separated from each other, they feel completely isolated. Their love and dependency on each other is consuming and obsessive. Their relationship really is not “romantic”. Catherine and Heathcliff were really “children” together. Catherine and Heathcliff spent their childhood together, but she met Edgar when she was twelve, and her separation from Wuthering Heights and Heathcliff began at that time. She became engaged to Edgar at the age of fifteen which is when Heathcliff ran away. She married Edgar three years later, and a few months later Heathcliff returned. She died within the year, at age 19. So, she and Heathcliff never really had an opportunity to experience a mature, adult love together. The twist of fate that the writer shows was very unique and fascinated. So in my opinion, there is a great disparity of relationship between theirs and others, they still face the cruel and indifferent world to pursue their own relationship, which only belongs to them. It is pity that they cannot defeat the deluge of the pressure from the reality and they fail to express their love to each other and at their will. Maybe we can say that their relationship is eternal and pure love in the world.
ReplyDeleteGan Siaw Fui
J38855
BPTESL
SEMESTER 6
I just love this novel..It shows many twist in it especially the love...The relationship between Heathcliff and Catherine are examples of two people who love each other beyond the comprehension of most people. The story is one of tragedy, and because of Heathcliff’s actions, many readers have a hard time viewing him as a hero. However, if one truly understands the meaning behind Emily Bronte’s writing, the only emotion that can be felt for Heathcliff is that of sympathy and pity. Through no action of his own, and only because of his birthright, Heathcliff is denied his one true love.
ReplyDeleteWithout the pressures of social expectations and usurpers, Heathcliff and Catherine may have married and changed the course of their lives. With Catherine, Heathcliff was a sedate and accepting childlike figure. After Catherine deserts him to marry Linton, Heathcliff is unable to feel anything but hate and anger for others.
If Catherine and Heathcliff had been able to follow their hearts as Cathy and Hareton are, they would have experienced the greatest love possible. When Hareton and Cathy plant their garden at Wuthering Heights, and it begins to blossom, the reader understands that a rebirth is about to occur. Somehow it is known, through this symbolism, that all that was evil will turn to love. Heathcliff and Cathy will be united in death, and the love of Cathy and Hareton will bloom. Heathcliff is redeemed when even he recognizes this. He finally lets go of his feelings of bitterness and is joined with Catherine through death.
Fate, a term which seems to appear every so often in the everyday world, can be a powerful force when dealing with the predetermination of events. Whether in the past, present or future, fate can change how things were, or are supposed to. I myself have come across many incidents which I believe is due to fate and I learnt that everything that happens has a reason.
Family, class, and fate work cruelly against them, as do their own jealous and volatile natures, and much of their lives are spent in revenge and frustration. Yet there is something magnificent about the depth and intensity of their love.
The fate of star crossed lovers who are unable to enjoy passion in life is to find redemption through death. To not understand that this is a love story, one beyond the comprehension of most, is a great loss to readers. To feel a love so strongly and so deeply is something that most of us will never be lucky enough to experience, and may never be able to truly comprehend.
SIVASANGHARI A/P NADARAJAN
J36340
BP TESL SEM 8 ( UPM PJJ)
For me, Wuthering Height is a revengeful love of Heathcliff, the protagonist.
ReplyDeleteCatherine and Heathcliff’s love is based on their shared perception that they are identical. Catherine declares, famously, “I amHeathcliff,” while Heathcliff, upon Catherine’s death, wails that he cannot live without his “soul,” meaning Catherine. the passion of love between both of them is obviosly one of the most compelling and memorable aspects of the book.
Environment of the moors and same dwelling place gives both of cathy and heathcliff a greater change to develop their romantic love affair. their love exits on a higher or spiritual plane, they are soul mate , two people who have an affinity for each other which draws them together irressistibly.
Catherine decides to marry Edgar for his social status. she decided to marry Edgar for his social standards . though she is married to him, she feels an ardent love and desire for Heathcliff which is antisocial . she believes that is subordinate and that Heathcliff is part of her.
At the end, we can say that the unalloyed love of Heathcliff turns to anti-moral as well as anti-social because of Cathy’s ambition to get social standard and his own psychological problem. In Wuthering Heights Catherine and Heathcliff’s love is a direct challenge to those social forces of family and class which tyrannize, oppress and restrict individuals and their relationship.
chua wei thing
BP TESL ( J 38851 )
Wuthering Height, I feel that every lover need to read to see how Emily Bronte able represent the love saga between Heathcliff and Catherine in a thoughtful manner. I consider their love just next to Romeo and Juliet and their relationship enable me to amaze the force that love has in bringing two souls together eventhough after death.
ReplyDeleteI believe that love between Heathcliff and Catherine is constant and deep. Both of them constant companion and defenders during their childhood. As adolescence , both of them assume that they will always be together. But fate has it own roles towards them. When Catherine decided to marry Edgar, it devasted Heathcliff without knowing the truth. Catherine , on the other hand married to Edgar in hope to rise Heathcliff and place him out her brother’s power. She didn’t feel any sense of shame over this dubious matrimonial motivate because she always believe the love she had towards Heathclif is eternal but her plan didn’t work after Heathcliff leaves Wuthering Heights.
Heathcliff is still drawn to Catherine when she dies at an early age and feel hunted by her spiritual presence. His depth passion towards her can be seen when he desires to see and embraces Catherine ‘s corpase and openly states that he wants to be buried with Catherine . He repeatedly calls Catherine his soul. Now, how many of us dare to say and do as Heathcliff ? Love is not like changing clothes as we can see in today’s fast growing world. Love that exist between Catherine and Heathclif is a life force relationship where it is not conditioned by anything but itself which bring a profound living signifance. This what I called a TRUE LOVE. Both of them are meant to be soulmate where the love exist on a higher or spiritual plane which draws them together irresistibly in whatever situation.
People normally afraid and seek healers or shaman to protect or chase ghost but not like Heathcliff where he strangely happy when the spirit of Catherine not let him rest and hunt him until they are reunited in death. I’m amazed and admit true love never die or disappear if one left the real world. In such case , Heathcliff feels and saw the Catherine everywhere he looks it as a passion of eternal love which is still burning in these two wonderful souls.
Furthermore for me, Catherine and Heathcliff’s love can be accepted as addictive love because both of them want to break down obstacles of identify and merge the lover into one identity. We can see these aspect when there is loss of lover or death in the case of Catherine and Heathcliff, both of them show withdrawal symptoms such as illnes , not eating and fainted. The addict lover wants possesion of the lover whatever consequence happen to the loved one like Catherine hunting Heathcliff for twenty years just to be with him. What an IDEAL LOVE !
Lastly I find that their love has meaning because they are rejecting the emptiness of the universe and social institutions which stand against them by finding meaning in their relationship with each other through inexorable connection between love and death in their speeches and actions.
Love has only one aim, that is to love and being loved in return. That was the case with Cathy and Heathcliff. It doesn’t matter how one choose to love. Heathcliff is brutal in nature as we read so was the way he sought to prove his love for Cathy. How would I classify their relationship? Well although they did not end up marrying each other, not many lovers do, but theirs were never-ending love, they continued loving each other until the day they die. Perhaps it continued in their life after death. However I began to wonder is love supreme compared to other values such as dignity, honesty and spirituality. Why was Cathy seemed blind and doesn’t consider these values before she chooses to love someone ‘truely’.Despite how Heathcliff was treated during his childhood and after the passing of his step-father Earnshaw, he can always choose to be a good man. He doesn’t have to revenge his step-brother nor Cathy instead he can always look for a right life partner and be happy. The novel can turn out to be an inspiring for the readers.
ReplyDeleteGIRIJA A/P RAMDAS
J38853
The love between Catherine and Heathcliff stunned me. The way Emily describes their love is so strong untuk they think they are each other soul.
ReplyDeleteHeathcliff and Catherine love exist on a higher or spiritual plane lavel. They need each other to fill their emptiness. Catherine wild passion nature draws her close to Heathcliff as she claims Heathcliff and her have the same passion. But in her logical way, Catherine knows Heathcliff cannot fulfil her social desire to be the upper class. So she choose to marry Edgar.
Her marriage to Edgar makes her realised her betrayal to herself. She realised Heathcliff is the only one that she love but it is too late. She already done too deep damaged to Heathcliff and Edgar that cannot be revived.
Since Catherine marriage, Heathcliff live in revenge and hatred. He makes everyone suffers including Catherine by marrying Isabella. But when Catherine is dying, he realised his love towards Catherine never ends. He hates as much as he loves Catherine. Even after Catherine die, he cannot free himself from her. He wants to bury with Catherine when he die without any wall separate between them and asks Catherine soul to hunt him until he die.
Catherine towards Heathcliff unfathomable love really puzzled me. She can loves him so deep as Heathcliff was herself but she can choose to give up that love instead of social standard and ended regret about her choice. To make a relationship works really hard. It needs persistence, perseverance and a lot of responsibility. If Catherine stand up to her feeling honestly she wouldn't die remorsefully.
I would categorize Catherine and Heathcliff relationship as emotionally and physically attraction relationship. Their love was not true and pure. In my opinion, true love need to accept entirely the one that we love including his/her economy and social status. Both lovers should be strong enough to face any obstacle and willing to sacrifice to achieve happiness in their lives.
ReplyDeleteIn Chapter 9, Catherine said "Nelly, I am Heatchcliff." This statement was just the idea and feeling of Catherine that behind all passionate love between a man and a woman is the natural urge to make one of two, to achieve identification with the beloved. But did Catherine decision to marry Edgar had shown the oppose meaning of her statement? Well it is easy to say anything but to do what we say is not that easy without true heart and soul. I can say that Catherine did not have true love towards Heathcliff. She refused to marry Heathcliff just because of the social status reason. Her arrogant, selfish and greedy attitudes made her to marry Edgar so that she would live in high level society status. Her action had turned everything into disaster and ruined others live.
For Heathcliff, his love toward Catherine was true but he does not owned a pure love. Although his heart had been crushed by the broken relationship, it does not mean that he should takes revenge with the situation by abusing and torturing others live. He should let the failure relationship taken away by time and just keep his love and sweet memories with Catherine in his heart. Once we do hear a statement that loving a person does not mean that we should own the person physically. He should not married Isabella as the aim of revenge. Heathcliff was the beast that had manipulated others live including his own son, Linton as objects of his satisfaction towards revenge.
Thanks.
ZIZIE ARDINA LIM ABDULLAH
J38867
BP TESL SEM 6
Dear Puan Ju,
ReplyDeleteHonestly when I found out about these extra tasks and reading the word "redemption" I can't help but to feel very curious as to how bad did we do in the final exam. LOL. I hope we didn't disappoint you that much and I am very grateful for the chance you're giving us now.
As for Wuthering Heights, much to my own amazement, I enjoyed reading the story (yes it was my first time!). Rather than focusing on the 'dark side' of this story, the strong feelings both Heathcliff and Catherine had for each other never failed to put me in awe.
However, reading on this story, the 'love' that was felt so strongly before turned into some sort of "one-ness" between the two characters. Catherine considers herself as Heathcliff which showed what she felt for the latter was beyond love at that moment. Instead of lovers, they are "soul mates", which is not always a very good thing when two people are in love.
How would I categorize their relationship? It's an unrequited love they are in and I'd say it's a relationship I wouldn't want to experience. Though they felt love at first, in the end when they didn't end up together, that love turned into a revenge and hurt everyone around them.
I was enchanted at how their fates got twisted but as someone who loves a "happy-ending" story, I find it quite unsettling when Heathcliff's anger started to turn him into an antagonist. Even though he was the victim for all the unfairness he had to endure when Mr Earnshaw left him for good, I expected him to look at the flip side of the coin of all the happenings in his life. But then, it is easier said than done. That would definitely not work in real life too unless one's will is really strong.
The twist and the "ugliness" of the excessive emotions didn't make me happy reading this story, but those what makes this book intriguing, and the relationship between Heathcliff and Catherine very interesting.
I hope I have answered all your questions. This is personally what I felt regarding the issues raised in this discussion.
Thank you.
-NUR HAFIZA HASAN
-J 38860 (BPTESL Sem 6)
hema j38837
ReplyDeleteFirst of all it takes me quite some time to get into the story of 'Wuthering Heights' as the author uses the same names for the second part of the story. It really confused me and i took some time to understand the family web before understanding the story.I believe that Catherine and Heathcliff do not have the true love for each other. Catherine mind changes when she met Edgar and Heathcliff wants to take revenge on her. A true love will not see anything except for the genuine feelings and emotion. A true love between two hearts will not have the feeling of hatred and revenge. Catherine has used the society status as a reason to marry Edgar. This clearly shows that she doesn't have the true love towards Heathcliff. As for Heathcliff, he has spoilt many lives included himself just to take revenge on Catherine. I will never blame the fate for all the incidents happened in their lives because fate can be changed by human beings who believes in themselves and their true love. The love between Catherine and Heathcliff in this story does not impressed me or touched my heart in any ways. The untruthe love between both of them has been carried to the second generation and tortures many lives. I personally believe that true love will not hurt anybody and one will sacrifice anything for true love.
Thks Dr Ju.
The relationship between Heathcliff and Cathy is a very complex one. Yes, they have a strong feeling towards each other but the truth is that none of them really understand what the other is feeling until it is too late. To me, lack or failure of communication between Heathcliff and Cathy contributes to their separation. It is such a pity when two people who realize that they love each other end up not being together.
ReplyDeleteI do not think that the display of emotions in “Wuthering Heights” is excessive. If anything, they only show how strong Heathcliff and Cathy’s feelings are towards each other. These scenes include how Cathy reacted when Heathcliff leaves Wuthering Heights and Heathcliff’s reaction when Cathy dies. These scenes are very powerful that seem to stick into the readers’ mind for a long time. For a self-proclaimed romantic person like me, I can truly understand how the heart can override the mind. Love works in mysterious ways. I believe Emily Bronte only wishes to portray what a lost love can do to a person. Personally I think the moral of the story is when you love somebody you must fight for it. If two persons are really soulmates, they should strive to be together. Otherwise they would end up being the lost souls like Heathcliff and Catherine.
PUTERI MARINA MOSTAFA
J38845 (BPTESL SEM6)
the relationship of heathcliff and catherine makes me feel so sad...
ReplyDeletewhy 2 people who are in love with each other could not be together? if heathcliff is brave enough to confess his love towards catherine, i am sure the fate of this couple would end up in another way. is really status and financial so important? i believe if two people really love each other, they could overcome everything that comes ahead.
a man who could love until the end of his life like heathcliff, is somebody that i dream to have. his love stands so firm and this is what i think to be called 'forever'.
heathcliff does everything to love catherine, but his lost for not able to be with catherine might be one of the reasons of his revenge. he always wants to be with catherine, even he becomes a ghost and this shows the deepnest and the sincerity of this man.
though the two of them had gone through so many unhappiness, at least the story gives a happy ending where the their ghost at last could be together.
i hope people in this world could be dare enough to tell the person they love before they regret of losing him or her. maybe the love might not be accepted, but trying brings no harm and at least there is a chance of hope. never be like heathcliff and catherine.... keeping their feelings of love in hearts.
(: tq
BABY TEH LING CHEE
BPTESL PJJ J38846 2010/2011
To me, Heathcliff and Catherine’s relationship is very intriguing and frustrating. They are not physically involved with each other (they do not kiss or arrange secret trysts like adulterers do) but they seem to love each other MADLY. While Catherine claims that she loves Heathcliff, she marries Edgar instead to pursue her social ambition but she refuses to adapt to her role as a wife either by sacrificing Heathcliff or embracing Edgar. Catherine’s action (to marry Edgar) traps her relationship with Heathcliff in a pit so deep and makes their lives miserable throughout the story.
ReplyDeleteTheir relationship is frustrating because they never get together in the end except that they are buried together, I do not consider it as “together” because Edgar’s tomb is placed with them and of course there is no togetherness after death in the story although Heathcliff wants physical togetherness by driving to see her corpse and making his arrangements for their corpses to merge by decaying into each other.
Heathcliff and Catherine represent the essential isolation of the soul, the agony of two souls, two halves of a single soul, forever sundered and struggling to reunite. Perhaps it is because they never get the chance to be together that makes them love, long and want for each other so strong.
Sia Nga Yea
J38864
I would say that the relationship between Heathcliff and Catherine as a very addictive love. They shared childhood together and hate to be apart. They regarded themselves as soul mates and even proclaimed to be the other half for one another. Heathcliff, the protagonist character in this story, portrays a very strong addiction toward his relationship with Catherine. When Catherine left him and married to Edgar, his love towards Catherine turns into hatred. He was completely loss control of himself and took revenge on Catherine by marrying Isabella. The failure to have Catherine as his life partner made him to take nothing as important as his own feelings. His plan of revenge eventually brings hurting to everyone around him who included his wife Isabella and his son Linton. Besides that, his strong addiction can be seen in the willingness to let himself to be haunted by Catherine ghost until the day death claims his life. He was too passionate in loving Catherine and the feeling never grow lesser for twenty years after Catherine‘s death. The addictive characteristic was also shown by Catherine. She was very in love with Heathcliff and have the sacrificial heart to marry Edgar and at the same time planning to help Heathcliff to improve his social standard and get freed from the empowerment by her brother. Sadly her plan did not work out but turn to be worsen when Heathcliff misunderstand her. Being too obsess in loving Heathcliff, Catherine losses the ability to value her own life and chose to live in grief and sorrow after Heathcliff married Isabella to take revenge on her. She allowed sadness to take control of her life and grew ill and died. Being too addictive toward their love story, both Heathcliff and Catherine really had a hard life. They were too obsess in their love story and missed the true meaning of lives one should live. Many may regard their spirit as true love but in my opinion, loving a person doesn’t mean that we must have him or her in our life. We shall never see nor treat someone we love as an object that is a must for us to possess in our life. The most important value to learn from this story is that we shall never let love overtake our rationalism and ignore our own needs and also the importance of people or things surround us.
ReplyDeleteYap Geok Peng
J38869 (BPTESL sem6)
Dear Madam,
ReplyDeleteTo say in a simple way of thought, love is love and that it brings you happiness. When love lost its passion,warm and affection, it is no longer called “love”. It likes darkness in reality of light’s absence. This is the way I describe the relationship between Heathcliff and Cathy .
To be honest, I am really repulsed of their relationship. I wonder why Heathcliff let himself so much possessed by vindiction and hatred rather than allow himself to grow forgiveness. For me, love does forgive and that forgiveness heals wound. Heathcliff should forgive cahty for being materialistic and individualistic to harvest tranquality of mind and allow himself to be loved and to love again.
As for Cathy, she should be very steadfast on her own decision so she would not hurt people who love her very much. She had decided to be Mrs.Linton, so she should be in Linton side, at least not to betray a person who loves her for the second time.
What’s troubling me on their relationship is the way they victimizing innocent people arounf them for they keep on believing that they still love to each other when actually they were not in that passion again. For examples, the abuse Catherine and Ms. Linton by Heathcliff, and the dissapointment of Mr. Linton knowing that Cathy still in love with Heathcliff.
However it is, judging is not an easy task. It’s really unspeakable a hard one, specially dealing with love. What we think is right way not necessarily is the same way to others. Let’s just say, anything dealing with feelings are so complicated.
saria Limpot
J38828
sem6